Two
of the carpet examples, PVC-backed and thermoplastic-backed, have
low-compression, un-cushioned-performance backings. Properties of the backing
(density and thickness) and face fiber create useful anti-fatigue properties.
This substantiates that cushion is not necessary for comfort when it comes to
carpet. Also shown are results for a carpet with a thin attached urethane
cushion, which possesses good anti-fatigue performance. But anti-fatigue performance
without a cushion is essential to having underfoot comfort and manageable
rolling resistance since, as shown, carpet with a cushion creates significantly
higher rolling resistance.
Protecting Patients
No
discussion of the benefits of carpet in healthcare facilities is complete
without bringing up infection control. It has been widely believed that carpet
in healthcare, tile or broadloom, harbors infectious microbes of all types. And
it was further believed that the seams inherent to carpet tiles were certain to
have high concentrations of microbes and be susceptible to leak-through by
bio-contaminated spills.
But
research proves otherwise. One study that ultimately involved 90 facilities has
shown that of all the surfaces found in healthcare – walls, floors, furniture,
doors – flooring is the surface least likely to
be part of transmitting infections.[1] Other recent findings show that smooth,
hard-flooring surfaces are much more likely to transmit infections than carpet
surfaces.[2] One
university study in a clinical setting found no higher concentration of
microbes at carpet tile seams (on top of the tile, at the seam edges, and below
the seam) than at any other point on any other type of flooring.[3]
The
U.S. Centers for Disease Control has recommended the use of carpet tiles or
modular carpeting in those areas where carpet is necessary and where
contaminated spills are a concern citing ease of removal, replacement and
decontamination or disposal as the key reasons for this.[4]
Curtailing Airborne Noise
Aside
from infection prevention, carpet also creates a better sound environment for
patients to heal. In fact, carpet plays a critical role in keeping the sources
of noise in healthcare, including equipment such as telephones, pagers,
monitors and alarms, paging systems, wheeled equipment, TV speakers, pneumatic
tube systems, ice makers, elevators and automatic doors, at a minimum.
Compared
to the hard surfaces typically found in healthcare, such as luxury vinyl tile,
rubber flooring, engineered flooring and VCT, carpet absorbs between 15–25
percent of airborne noise, compared to only 0-5 percent for the hard surfaces
mentioned. Perhaps more important, carpet is especially effective in absorbing
those frequencies common to background noise, which dramatically improves
speech recognition. Carpet is similarly effective at reducing structure-borne
sound. It usefully absorbs between 50–55 percent of structure borne sound
compared to 20–25 percent for hard surfaced flooring.[4]
Good
acoustics translate directly into better staff performance and patient
outcomes. More than any other surface, carpet effectively absorbs background
noise, loud disturbing sounds such as monitors, alarms, paging systems and cell
phones, and structure-borne noise. All of these are disturbing and undesirable.
They interfere with rest, which interferes with recovery. Only carpet provides
acoustic management which, combined with good noise reduction programs, creates
an environment favorable to good patient outcomes, and patient satisfaction as
reflected in Press-Gainey exit surveys.
Healing Mother Earth
Carpeting
not only benefits caregivers and patients, but it is also good for the
environment. Today, there are multiple carpet solutions
available that are certified by third-party environmental organizations, such
as the Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI). There are also carpet options
available that contain pre- and post-consumer content and have non-PVC
thermoplastic modular backing technology that can be recycled back into itself.
Properly
maintained, carpeting stays in use and out of the waste stream longer,
contributing to lower life-cycle costs, saving healthcare facilities money.
Furthermore, when product, installation and maintenance supplies and labor
costs are considered over a 15-to 20-year period, carpet delivers lower
life-cycle costs than other floor coverings. It is also important to note that
a carpet’s life cycle may be extended if the carpeting features a permanent
stain resistance system allowing for cleaning with water instead of harsher
chemicals that are then emitted in the downstream wastewater treatment
facilities.
Another
benefit of carpet is its low volatile organic compound (VOC) levels improving
the indoor air quality and lessening its impact on the environment. It has been
found that carpet may emit the lowest levels of VOC among common flooring
choices and is one of the lowest emitting products used in new construction and
renovation, much lower than products such as paint.[5] To identify those selections that have
been recognized as the most lowest emitting, look for the CRI Green Label
certification.
Considering the advantages,
including recyclability, cushioning, low-rolling resistance and infection
control, it is clear why carpet is increasingly specified for progressive
healthcare facilities. It is not only beneficial to patients and caregivers,
but also the environment and the facility’s bottom line.
1.
Carling PC,
Perry MF, et al. Identifying opportunities to enhance environmental cleaning in
23 acute care hospitals. Infect Control
Hosp Epidemiol 2008;29:1-7
2.
Leib R, Rhode J,
Are those room finishes and cleaners safe? Healthcare
Design 2007; 2
3.
Harris D, A
study of carpet tile viability. Facility
Care 2008; 13:14 – 18
4.
Based on results
of testing by an accredited laboratory per ASTM E423-08 and ASTM E2179-03
By: Janae
Posted: June 28, 2010 8:45 AM
There are a number of RESILIENT flooring products that don't ask you to compromise on safety. Resilient flooring is widely available with a cushion attached for comfort under foot. Resilient is better in my book. Resilient products have been designed for optimal comfort under foot, sound absorption, rolling cart load ease, but most importantly, resistant to bacteria. Specify CLEAN floors in CLEAN areas.